MCU's Phase 5 Villains

October 13, 2023
4 min read
By George Djaniants
Fan Theories
MCU s Phase 5 Villains

Marvel's Cinematic Universe (MCU) has always been adept at showcasing large-scale conflicts and cosmic-scale destruction. Yet, as we venture into Phase 5, the scale of devastation, both moral and physical, is now set on a multiverse level, dwarfing the cataclysmic actions of Thanos in "Infinity War".

To understand the sheer enormity of what Phase 5 introduces, we need to revisit the gravity of Thanos' actions. In "Infinity War", through a snap of his fingers powered by the Infinity Stones, Thanos eradicated half of all life across the universe. His rationale, albeit twisted, was rooted in a desire for balance, ensuring that the remaining half could thrive without the burden of overpopulation and resource depletion.

However, with the introduction of the Time Variance Authority (TVA) and its subsequent rogue faction in "Loki" season 2, the MCU has revealed a threat that makes Thanos' genocidal snap appear almost trivial. The TVA, in their pursuit to maintain the "Sacred Timeline" and avoid a multiversal war, undertook a mission to prune branches of the timeline. These branches, contrary to their tree-like analogy, aren't mere offshoots but represent entire universes teeming with life, history, and potential futures.

General Dox and the Sacred Timeline

A key character in this new chaos is General Dox. By the second episode of "Loki" season 2, she emerges as a significant player, taking upon herself the mission to correct the multiversal disarray caused by Sylvie's earlier actions. Under her guidance, a band of rogue TVA hunters embark on an alarming mission. They seek out and obliterate various timeline branches, believing it to be in service of a greater good: the preservation of a single, unfractured timeline, one that has been dubbed the "Sacred Timeline".

But what does it mean to destroy a timeline branch? Each obliterated branch denotes the annihilation of an entire universe. Think of countless worlds, civilizations, species, and narratives getting extinguished in a heartbeat. The number of lives lost would be in the billions for just one universe; now consider the destruction of multiple universes. The scale becomes almost unfathomable. Even Thanos' universe-altering snap pales in comparison, as he wiped out half, while the TVA's actions led to the complete obliteration of existence in numerous universes.

The Dichotomy of the Greater Good

Both Thanos and the TVA justify their respective actions under the guise of the "Greater Good". However, the nature and motivation behind their actions are vastly different, leading us to question the very definition of this so-called good.

Thanos' method, while horrific, was indiscriminate. His snap did not choose based on class, race, or power. To him, every life was equal in the eyes of balance. There was a twisted fairness in his action, which was rooted in a desire for equilibrium.

On the other hand, the TVA's approach, especially under the directives of He Who Remains and subsequently, General Dox's faction, is more calculated and selective. Their mission targets specific branches that stray from the pre-decided Sacred Timeline. Any deviation, be it minor or significant, is deemed a threat. This approach showcases a troubling dogma. Variants, or those that diverge from the approved timeline, are seen as imperfections. Figures like Sylvie and other versions of Loki are viewed as outliers, and their very existence is seen as a challenge to the ordained path.

This targeted elimination is a far cry from balance. It doesn't seek harmony but rather a rigid adherence to a single deemed "correct" timeline. Any potential goodness, innovation, or divergence in these variants is dismissed and destroyed in favor of maintaining an established order. It's an approach that reeks of tyranny, seeking to mold the multiverse in a singular vision.

Final Thoughts

As MCU's Phase 5 unfolds, it compels viewers to grapple with profound moral and philosophical questions. What does it mean to maintain order at the expense of diversity? How do we define the greater good, and who gets to decide its parameters? As we've seen, the consequences of such decisions have multiversal ramifications.

The TVA's actions, when placed in contrast with Thanos', shed light on different forms of villainy. While one sought balance through randomness, the other seeks uniformity through precision. As the narrative progresses, it remains to be seen how heroes and anti-heroes of the MCU navigate this complex web of morality, choice, and consequence.

But one thing is clear: the stakes have never been higher. The MCU continues to push boundaries, challenging both its characters and its audience to confront the weighty implications of power, authority, and the very nature of existence. Phase 5 is not just an escalation in scale, but also in depth, and it promises to be a thrilling ride.

Published on October 13, 2023 by George Djaniants

George Djaniants

CEO & Co-Founder